這篇筆記： 每個點怎麼用「點、機制、例子、結果」寫完整，三種題型各自怎麼選點，換面向的句型框，以及把 gap year 四個點重新分配的示範。
Advantages/Disadvantages 題型｜共 3 篇
- 1. 題型、鏡像重複與三組面向
- 2. 寫完整、選點、句型與示範（你正在讀）
- 3. 常見錯誤、流程與練習
四、每個點都要寫完整：點、機制、例子、結果
點分開之後，下一步是把每個點寫完整。四段結構一段要放兩個點，每個點大約 50–60 字，我用四個問題檢查：
| 問題 | 要寫的內容 | 常用開頭 | 句數 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 是什麼？ | 點本身（主題句） | The primary one is that … ／ Secondly, … | 1 |
| 為什麼會這樣？ | 機制：中間經過哪些步驟 | This is because … ／ In other words, … | 1 |
| 例如？ | 具體情境、身邊的例子 | For instance, … ／ … is a good example of this. | 1 |
| 所以呢？ | 結果落在誰身上、造成什麼 | As a result, … ／ Consequently, … | 0–1 |
四段結構裡，「例如」和「所以呢」可以二選一，但「為什麼會這樣」最好不要省，因為它是讓點和點之間不重複的關鍵：機制寫出來，你自己就會發現兩個點是不是同一條路。
寫得完整的例子：第 43 篇優點二
If children know that they can success after working hard, they will make an effort to enhance their capabilities and focus on their realms, further fostering their professions. Consequently, the ability of the younger generation will undeniably rise simultaneously, which increases the competitiveness of the society.
這兩句是一條完整的鏈：相信努力有用 → 願意投入、提升能力 → 專業能力成長 → 年輕世代整體能力上升 → 社會競爭力提高。每一步都在回答上一步的「所以呢」。文法上要修兩個地方：can success 應為 can succeed；focus on their realms 的 realms 很少這樣用，寫 their chosen fields 就自然了。
寫得太薄的例子：第 15 篇缺點二
Secondly, the concern of road safety will increase simultaneously if the driverless vehicles are used on the roads. For instance, car accidents may happen easily without the supervision by humans.
只有兩句，而且 For instance 後面不是例子，是把主題句換個說法再講一次。缺的是「為什麼」：自駕車為什麼會不安全？是系統判斷錯誤、遇到突發狀況反應不了，還是被駭客入侵？補上機制和一個情境，這個點才算展開：
改寫示範：Another concern is road safety. Self-driving systems rely on sensors and software, which may fail to recognise unexpected situations such as a child running into the street or a road sign covered by snow. When this happens, there is no human driver to take control, so a minor error could quickly become a serious accident.
改了什麼：用 rely on sensors and software 說出機制；用兩個具體情境取代空泛的 car accidents may happen；最後一句說出結果（小錯變大事故）。這樣它跟優點的「省錢、環保」也完全分屬不同面向（安全），不會被看成重複。
五、三種題型的選點策略不一樣
同樣是想出優缺點，三種題型「挑哪幾個點」的標準不一樣。這張表是我現在想點時的判斷方式：
| 題型 | 選點原則 | 用面向來安排 |
|---|---|---|
| 純優缺點 | 兩邊份量相近，不要一邊很重一邊很輕 | 優缺點各有一個個人層次、一個社會層次，讀起來最平衡 |
| 優缺點＋意見 | 支持的一方挑影響大、能延伸的點；另一方挑可以被處理的點 | 支持的一方放「長期」或「社會」，另一方放「短期」或「個人」，結論自然可以表態 |
| Outweigh | 支持的一方兩點，讓步一點 | 讓步點挑「短期、範圍小、可解決」；結論說明為什麼它比較輕 |
以試改（26A）來說，我的結論是 gap year 利大於弊，並用一句話說缺點可以被處理：
Furthermore, the implementation of regulations and loans from banks can tackle the downsides concerning this issue.
方向是對的，但「銀行貸款」拿來解決「旅費負擔」，其實是用借錢解決沒錢，反而可能加重經濟壓力。gap year 範文那篇（gap year 6.5 分範文）有詳細的改寫。從選點的角度看，如果一開始就在缺點那邊挑「容易被處理」的點，結論的解法就不會這麼勉強。
六、句型框：讓讀者一眼看出你換了面向
點分開之後，也要讓讀者看得出來。主題句裡放一個「面向訊號」，閱卷者一眼就知道你換了角度，不會誤以為你在重複。
段落開頭（我常用的骨架）
There are some reasons why … seems to be beneficial. The primary one is that … Another factor is that …
However, … is sometimes disadvantageous. First and foremost, … Secondly, …
The purpose of this essay is to analyze both merits and demerits of this phenomenon.（純優缺點的開頭第二句）
面向訊號
On a personal level, … ／ For individuals, …
At a broader level, society as a whole may also benefit, since …
In the short term, … ; in the long run, however, …
Financially, … ／ In terms of health, … ／ From an educational perspective, …
Apart from the financial cost, another drawback is that …
A less obvious disadvantage is that …
結論（依題型）
純優缺點：In conclusion, … can bring A and B; nevertheless, it may also lead to C and D.
優缺點＋意見：In conclusion, although … may cause C, I believe the benefits are greater because A and B have a longer-lasting impact.
Outweigh：In conclusion, the benefits of A and B outweigh the drawback of C, which is only temporary and can be reduced by …
Apart from the financial cost 這類句子特別好用：它明白告訴讀者「錢的部分我講完了，接下來是別的面向」，等於幫你證明兩個缺點不重複。
七、示範：把 gap year 的四個點重新分配
回到 gap year 這題（優缺點＋意見，原題見第 1 篇），用面向表重新挑四個點，避開原文「工作」那一欄的衝突：
| 點 | 主題 | 層次／時間 |
|---|---|---|
| 優點一：工作經驗讓學生更清楚自己想讀什麼科系 | 能力、學習 | 個人／長期 |
| 優點二：旅行或休息一年，紓解升學壓力 | 健康（心理） | 個人／短期 |
| 缺點一：學習節奏中斷，回到課堂需要重新適應 | 學習習慣 | 個人／短期 |
| 缺點二：旅費常常落在父母身上，或讓學生提早負債 | 經濟 | 家庭／中期 |
優點一和缺點一都跟「學習」有關，但一個是「方向變清楚」，一個是「節奏被打斷」，機制不同，通過反義測試（「節奏被打斷」的反義是「讀書習慣維持住」，不是「方向變清楚」）。寫成段落如下：
示範（優點段）：There are some reasons why taking a gap year can be beneficial. The primary one is that working for a year helps school leavers decide what they really want to study. After experiencing the daily routine of an office or a restaurant, many young people discover which tasks they enjoy, so they are less likely to choose a university major simply because it is popular. Another advantage is psychological. After years of preparing for exams, a year of travelling or working gives students time to rest, which allows them to start university with more energy and curiosity.
示範（缺點段）：However, a gap year also has its drawbacks. First and foremost, students may find it difficult to return to academic life. After twelve months without lectures or deadlines, some of them struggle to concentrate on reading and revision again, and they may fall behind classmates who went straight to university. Apart from this, the financial cost can be considerable. Since most school leavers have no stable income, the expense of travelling often falls on their parents, or the students have to borrow money before their studies have even begun.
對照原文，這兩段做了三件事：第一，四個點分屬能力、健康、學習習慣、經濟，沒有一組是同一件事的正反面；第二，缺點段用 Apart from this 明確標示換了面向；第三，缺點二講的是「錢落在誰身上」，把層次從個人拉到家庭，結論要表態時，也可以順勢說「有薪的實習計畫可以減輕這個負擔」。
繼續讀 · 第 3 / 3 篇
IELTS 寫作攻略導覽 · 大作文架構（第 5 / 9 篇）
← 上一篇：Discuss both views：段落順序、結論四步驟與立場一致
下一篇 →：Outweigh 與優缺點：四段還是五段？讓步段、結論怎麼「秤重」
✦ Target Your Future
有些日子，明明練了很久，成績卻還停在原地。希望這篇筆記能讓你知道，備考路上遇到挫折並不孤單。一次次重聽的錄音、改過的作文、終於敢說出口的句子，都是你已經走過的路。
把這些經驗寫下來，是想陪下一個正在準備的人少繞一點路。你不必照著我的方法前進，只需要慢慢找到適合自己的節奏。累的時候可以休息，再回來做今天能完成的一小步。
願你最後帶走的，不只是成績單上的數字，還有更相信自己、敢往世界走近一點的勇氣。
— Ting
← 回到 IELTS 備考筆記
Leave a Reply